The Best This Bahamian Out Island Has to Offer
In late February 2019, the U.S. Department of State issued a travel advisory for the Bahamas, warning tourists against violent assaults. Hardly a pretty picture, right? But the Department of State also noted that “the vast majority of crime occurs on New Providence and Grand Bahama islands,” not the archipelago’s so-called family islands.
For travelers only familiar with Nassau, it’s easy to forget that the Bahamas is comprised of some 700 little landmasses, 14 of which are considered out islands or (in the words of their inhabitants) family islands. One of these is Eleuthera, a 112-mile-long sliver of stony ground with a population barely in the five digits.
Astonishing beaches, stupendous surfing, a warm populace, and (for the present time) a surprising lack of development await visitors. Rocker Lenny Kravitz, who lives on the island, told Travel + Leisure, “Where I am, there’s nothing, which is what’s beautiful about it. It’s more raw.”
Yes, it’s raw, but in Eleuthera, Bahamas, things to do just seem a little more magical. Following you’ll find a list of some of the island’s must-see spots.
Visit Preacher’s Cave
Drive north up the Queen’s Highway (the single main road on Eleuthera) through a stretch of woods and almost to the island’s tip, and you’ll find the birthplace of the Bahamas. In the mid-17th century, a Puritan named William Sayle shipwrecked right off the coast. When his bedraggled crew of political and religious dissidents made it to the beach they immediately looked for shelter — and found it in a cavern that would come to be known as Preacher’s Cave.
The grotto is like most things on this family island: rugged, unspoiled and breathtaking. Aside from a small modern-day plaque detailing the history and an older carving on a rock slab written hundreds of years ago, the area is untouched. A geological amphitheater soaring some 50 feet high, the cave makes you reconsider what the word means.
Dramatically lit by sunlight filtering, boggling in its soaring height, and crowded on all sides by encroaching jungle, it makes it easy to imagine the bedraggled refugees wondering what they got themselves into. The ferocious clouds of mosquitoes do also. Don’t forget the bug spray!
Dive the Sapphire Blue Hole
Mere minutes from Preacher’s Cave lies one of the top things to do in Eleuthera: the Sapphire Blue Hole. It deserves the name, too. A hollow every bit as deep as Preacher’s Cave is high, it contains some of the most stunningly blue water you will ever see in your life. Strip down, take a deep breath, and throw yourself off a ledge and some 20 feet down to the water below. Only the brave of heart and fleet of foot should try. The only way back up to your car comes via a knotted rope.
Divers will also find themselves in for a treat. A network of underwater caves extends below the hole. However, don’t attempt it without a knowledgeable guide. Outfits such as Miller’s Dive Shop and Diving Eleuthera can likely set you up with one. In a pinch, reach out to the Eleuthera Tourism Office (242-332-2142), and one of the helpful public servants will come to your aid.
Serbia will prove itself to be one of the most rewarding and surprising nations in Europe. Serbia tourism might be under the radar, but not for long!
Eat Sushi at The Cove
Due to the lack of development on the island, Eleuthera doesn’t have a bevy of restaurants to dine in. Asking locals is always a good plan. But if you have the least bit of liking for sushi, you owe it to yourself to visit The Cove.
Once a small family-run property perched on an isthmus that frames two beautiful bays, The Cove contains 55 rooms split between isolated villas, spacious suites and individual rooms. The property itself offers plenty of worthwhile diversions. But the real draw is its food.
Chef Joel Abelilla has studied under a Japanese sushi instructor, and not only does he use incredibly fresh fish, his inventions can also make the sushi-skeptical develop a yen for the Asian delicacy. The Hilltop Farms chicken katsu (local chicken, avocado, pineapple and wasabi) and Joey’s famous cove roll (a tempura-battered roll filled with crab, avocado and cream cheese that’s deep fried) are particularly good for beginners.
See Sea and Ocean Meet at Glass Window Bridge
The phrase “you have to see it to believe it” may be a cliche. However, it also happens to be true when it comes to Glass Window Bridge, one of the most popular things to do in Eleuthera. Located near the hamlet of Gregory Town, it’s a point where the land narrows to a width scarcely wider than a couple of cars, providing dramatic views of two very different bodies of water.
Turn to one side, and you’ll behold the Atlantic Ocean, a tossing, frothing, violent mass of water that looks almost indigo in color. Turn to the other side, and there’s the Bight of Eleuthera, pale green and perfectly calm. It’s hard to imagine a contrast more striking or more beautiful.
You can see some video I shot of this incredible spot here.
Ride the Waves at Surfer’s Beach
While the Pacific may boast some truly impressive waves, Surfer’s Beach shows that you can still hang ten in the Atlantic. This two-mile stretch of perfectly white sand on Eleuthera’s west shore has a reef just off it. The reef causes regular waves to break just so, and you can pretty much always catch one if you’re willing to lug a board down the skinny, mangrove-framed trails leading down from Queen’s Highway. Though often only medium sized, the surf can grow truly impressive during the winter months.
Didn’t bring a board with you? Contact Surfer Pete (242-335-5436) in nearby Gregory Town. Not only will he rent you a board, he’ll give you all the inside information about the sand, surf and surrounding environment that you could want.
You'll literally be able to walk into the past when you visit these ghost towns of America. Prepare yourself for a truly eerie yet informative experience.
Rent a Car and Explore South
Savvy travelers closely following this guide will soon realize that all these recommendations cluster on the northern part of the island. That’s not to suggest that the best things to do in Eleuthera are only found there. Indeed, the central and southern sections offer all sorts of charming sights. You can explore Alice Town, view the Hatchet Bay caves, splash in the shallows of Receiver’s Beach, discover local authors at Haynes Library, and visit the museum in the Mission House.
Of course, given Eleuthera’s length, you’ll need to rent a car to do so. Many locals will rent you a car for a daily cash rate of $65 to $75 USD. Additionally, Italian photographer Alessandro Sarno’s little coffee table book “White Bull on the Highway” not only contains great pictures of the island, it provides names and phone numbers of locals who can provide rooms, serve great meals, take you on adventures and generally show you the sights.